
In many healthcare organizations, the downtime plan lives with IT or nursing informatics, and the emergency operations plan (EOP) lives with the emergency management coordinator. They have different authors, different review calendars, and sometimes different notification lists. Each document is reasonable on its own. Together they can contradict each other at exactly the moment both are needed.
An EHR outage is an emergency by any practical definition. It can be caused by a hazard your EOP already addresses, such as a storm that takes out power, or it can be a hazard in its own right, such as ransomware. The CMS Emergency Preparedness Rule expects a single, coordinated program built on an all-hazards risk assessment. If your downtime plan sits outside that program, you are carrying a gap that is easy to fix and expensive to discover during a survey or a real event.
Why the Two Plans Drift Apart
- They are written by different teams at different times, often years apart
- The downtime plan is treated as a technology document, while the EOP is treated as a facilities and safety document
- Review cycles do not line up, so one plan reflects last year’s structure while the other reflects this year’s
- Neither plan names the other, so a reader of one has no idea the second exists
- Exercises test one plan at a time, so conflicts never surface
What CMS Expects, and Where Downtime Belongs
The rule is built on four core elements, with details that vary by provider type. The regulatory text for hospitals is at 42 CFR 482.15. Downtime has a natural home in each element.
- Risk assessment and planning. Your hazard vulnerability assessment should list technology failure and cyberattack as hazards, not only weather and fire
- Policies and procedures. Downtime procedures are part of continuity of operations, including how care and documentation continue when systems are unavailable
- Communication plan. The plan must name primary and alternate ways to reach staff, physicians, and entities providing services under arrangement. Your EHR vendor, staffing agencies, and other contracted services belong on that list
- Training and testing. Downtime training and exercises should be recorded as part of the emergency preparedness program, not kept in a separate file
Check the section of the rule that applies to your provider type, since requirements differ for hospitals, critical access hospitals, clinics, and other settings.
Related Frameworks That Point the Same Direction
- The HIPAA Security Rule requires contingency planning, including an emergency mode operation plan. See the HHS Security Rule overview. Our posts on HIPAA and EHR data access during an outage and downtime documentation and HIPAA go deeper
- The ONC SAFER Guides include a Contingency Planning guide focused on planned and unplanned EHR unavailability. For hospitals in CMS’s Promoting Interoperability Program, an annual SAFER self-assessment is part of program requirements, so contingency planning is likely already on someone’s calendar
- Accreditation standards for emergency management also expect a hazard assessment and tested response plans. See the Joint Commission standards for your accreditation manual
Put Downtime Into the Hazard Vulnerability Assessment
If the hazard vulnerability assessment does not list EHR outage scenarios, the EOP has no basis for prioritizing them. Add separate entries rather than a single line.
- Planned EHR downtime for upgrades and maintenance
- Unplanned EHR outage from software or hardware failure
- Cyberattack with extended unavailability
- Vendor or cloud-hosting outage outside your control
- Network or power failure affecting clinical systems
- Cascading scenarios, such as a storm leading to power loss leading to network failure. Our post on preparing for downtime caused by severe weather covers these in detail
Score each one for probability, impact, and current readiness, and score short and extended durations separately. A four-hour outage and a two-week outage deserve different ratings.
Fold Downtime Into Incident Command
Most hospitals organize emergency response using the Hospital Incident Command System or a similar structure built on NIMS. Decide in advance how downtime fits.
- Name the downtime coordinator’s role within the command structure. Clinical downtime operations typically sit in Operations, while IT restoration typically sits with a technology unit in Logistics
- Define activation criteria, such as expected duration, number of affected departments, suspected cyber cause, or patient safety concerns
- Map the tiers from your downtime command center to your incident command activation levels, so a Tier 3 downtime event automatically triggers a facility-level response
- Make sure the person who declares downtime and the person who declares an incident know about each other
Align the Communication Plans
- Use one notification tree, or at minimum make sure the two trees reference each other
- Include alternate channels that do not depend on the EHR or the building network, as described in our guide to a downtime communication plan
- List the EHR vendor, downtime solution vendor, and staffing agencies as entities under arrangement, with 24-hour contacts
- Test the list. Phone numbers that no longer work are the most common finding in any communication review
Count Downtime Practice as Emergency Plan Testing
Planned maintenance windows, tabletop exercises, and real activations are all opportunities to test the plan. Treat them as part of one exercise program.
- Build a combined scenario, such as an ice storm that causes power loss and leaves the EHR unavailable for 18 hours. The FEMA HSEEP approach is a useful structure for design and evaluation
- Use the tabletop exercise guide for leadership decisions and planned maintenance windows for hands-on practice
- Write after-action reports in one format, using the approach in our post on downtime after-action reports
- Confirm with your compliance team how actual activations and different exercise types may be counted for your provider type
Common Conflicts to Resolve
- Two different people each believe they are in charge during an outage
- Different definitions of when an event begins, so one plan is active while the other is dormant
- Surge plans that assume registration systems are available
- Supply caches for emergencies that do not include wristbands, labels, and printed downtime forms
- Evacuation and patient tracking procedures that depend on EHR data
- Training programs that cover one plan but not the other
Questions a Surveyor Might Ask
- Does your hazard assessment include an EHR or cyber event, and how was it rated?
- Where is downtime addressed in your emergency plan?
- Show me your last exercise that involved loss of electronic systems
- How are contracted and agency staff trained on these procedures? Our post on agency staff and the downtime training gap covers this
- How would you notify staff and physicians if the network were unavailable?
A Ten-Minute Crosswalk Exercise
Put the EOP and the downtime plan side by side and answer five questions.
- Does the EOP mention downtime procedures by name, with an owner?
- Does the downtime plan reference the EOP’s incident command structure?
- Do both documents use the same activation triggers?
- Do the communication plans use the same contacts and alternate channels?
- Does the exercise calendar include scenarios that involve both?
Every “no” is a task for your next planning meeting. For a broader look at how the whole program is performing, see the scorecard approach.
Where dbtech Fits
dbtech supports the evidence side of this alignment. The Downtime Dashboard shows whether workstations are current, eForms give each department a consistent documentation method, and an exercise built around the dbtech downtime solution produces the observation data that belongs in your exercise records. A Downtime Audit Assessment can also review how your downtime procedures line up with your emergency plan. To discuss it, contact our team or request a demo.